Note: This page explains how viruses work; it isn't medical advice.
Why are viruses not considered living? The short answer
Viruses are not considered living because they can't do anything on their own. A virus is just a set of genes wrapped in a protein coat. It has no cells, no metabolism of its own (it can't make energy by itself), it doesn't grow, and it has no machinery to build proteins.13 Outside a living cell, a virus is an inert particle that simply drifts.4
Viruses do make copies of themselves, but only by getting inside a living cell and taking over its machinery. The cell does all the work.2 So by the strict checklist biologists use for life, most scientists say viruses are not alive. Some scientists disagree, and call viruses a grey area at the very edge of life.56
What is a virus?
A virus is a tiny package with just two or three parts:25
- Genes: the instructions for making more viruses, written in DNA or RNA.
- A capsid: a protective coat made of protein, often built from many identical pieces.
- An envelope (only some viruses): a fatty outer layer taken from the last cell the virus left.
That's the basic plan (some viruses also carry a few enzymes). There are no cell parts inside, no ribosomes to build proteins, and no way to make energy.3 One microbiologist jokingly calls a virus "gift-wrapped" genetic material.5
Viruses are also incredibly small. Most are about 20 to 250 nanometres across (a nanometre is a millionth of a millimetre).2 A typical bacterium is 0.1 to 5 micrometres, so it's many times bigger, and your own cells are bigger still, at 10 to 100 micrometres.9 Scientists only got their first good look at viruses with the electron microscope, in the late 1930s.2
Are viruses living or nonliving? The checklist for life
Biology textbooks list the features all living things share: order, responding to the environment, reproduction, adaptation, growth and development, regulation (keeping conditions steady inside), energy processing, and evolution.1 Here's how a virus compares with three other things:
The cat and the bacterium tick every box on their own. A crystal can "grow" by adding atoms, but it has no genes and uses no energy. The virus is the odd one out: it has genes and it evolves (which is why flu vaccines are updated every year), yet it has no cells, no metabolism, and can't copy itself without a host.34 Whether a virus really "responds" is debated: it binds to cells, but only because of its shape and chemistry.4 The ✓ and ✗ marks in the table and in the player's test are our simple summary of these sources, not an official scoring system.
How does a virus make copies if it isn't alive?
It borrows a cell. A good example is a bacteriophage ("phage" for short), a virus that infects bacteria. The T4 phage, which infects the gut bacterium E. coli, looks like a tiny lunar lander: a head full of DNA on top of a tail with spindly fibres.210 Most virus infections follow the same basic steps:8
- Attach. The virus drifts until it bumps into the right kind of cell. Proteins on the virus fit matching spots (receptors) on the cell, like a key in a lock.
- Get in. A phage injects its genes and leaves its empty coat outside. Many other viruses are taken inside whole and then shed their coat.
- Take over. The virus's genes direct the cell's machinery to copy the viral genes and build viral proteins instead of the cell's own.
- Assemble. The new parts fit together into new viruses. In about half an hour, one bacterium infected by T4 can make roughly 100 to 200 new phages.10
- Release. The cell bursts open and the new viruses drift off to find more cells. Some viruses instead bud out through the cell's surface without bursting it.8
Notice what's missing: the virus never eats, never makes energy and never builds anything itself. That's the heart of why viruses are not considered living. The same thing happens when you catch a cold: a few virus particles get into the cells lining your nose, and a few days later huge numbers of new viruses have been made.3 More than 200 different viruses can cause colds; rhinoviruses are the most common.11 Bacteria are different: they are living cells with their own protein-making machinery, and most reproduce all by themselves by splitting in two.
Could viruses be alive after all? The case for "yes"
Not every scientist agrees that viruses are simply not alive, and the arguments are worth hearing:56
- The seed argument. Virologist David Bhella points out that a virus particle is inert in the same way a seed or a bacterial spore is. Nobody says a seed is dead; it's waiting for the right place to grow. Inside a cell, he argues, a virus is very much alive.5
- Giant viruses. In 2003 scientists described mimivirus, a giant virus found in amoebae. It's about 750 nanometres across, bigger than some bacteria, and its genome is about 1.2 million DNA letters long. It even carries genes linked to protein-making, a job that normally only cells do.35 Some researchers suggest giant viruses could form a "fourth domain" of life.5
- Nobody lives alone. Some bacteria, such as Chlamydia and Rickettsia, also need other cells to reproduce, yet we call them alive. (The difference: they still have their own ribosomes and protein-making machinery.)35
So viruses sit in a grey area. Scientific American describes them as "verging on life".6 Where you draw the line depends on how you define life: if life means "genes that can evolve", viruses count; if it means "can make its own proteins and energy", they don't. The "line of life" toy in the player lets you try different lines. Its rules are our simplified summaries of these positions, not official definitions.
Why do viruses exist?
You might wonder why something that isn't alive exists at all. The answer is that anything that gets itself copied more often than it's destroyed will stick around, and viruses are extremely good at getting cells to copy them. They're also hugely successful: there are thought to be around 1031 virus particles in the oceans (a one with 31 zeros), far more than all other living things on the planet put together.5
Viruses aren't just freeloaders, either. They move genes between living things. Some phages carry genes from one bacterium to another.12 And about 8% of the human genome is made of the remains of ancient viruses that got into the DNA of our distant ancestors and were passed down ever since.7 (DNA is the instruction book of life; see why DNA is important.)
Where do viruses come from?
Nobody knows for sure, and viruses leave no fossils. Scientists have three main ideas:3
- The escape idea: viruses began as bits of genetic material that could already move around inside cells, and gained the ability to move between cells.
- The reduction idea: viruses were once free-living cells that became parasites and gradually lost genes, until they could only copy themselves inside a host. Giant viruses fit this story well.
- The virus-first idea: viruses may be as old as cells, or older, descended from copying molecules that existed before the first cells.
Different kinds of virus may have started in different ways, and the answer may turn out to be a mix of all three.3
Why don't antibiotics work on viruses?
Because viruses aren't living cells. Antibiotics work by attacking parts of bacteria, such as their cell walls or their protein-making machinery. Viruses don't have those parts, so antibiotics can't touch them. That's why antibiotics don't help with colds, flu or most sore throats.13 (See how antibiotics work.)
What helps against viruses? Washing your hands with soap helps stop them spreading.16 Vaccines train your immune system to recognise a virus before you meet it,17 and antiviral medicines can block steps of a particular virus's copying cycle.14 Learn more in how vaccines work, or see how one especially slow virus travels through the body in how rabies works. And a nice twist: because phages kill only bacteria, doctors in some countries use them to treat bacterial infections, and in the US phage sprays are approved to kill Listeria germs on meat.14
Common misconceptions
"Viruses are just very small bacteria." Bacteria are living cells; viruses aren't cells at all, and they're usually much smaller.
29
"Antibiotics kill viruses." They don't. Vaccines and antiviral medicines work against viruses.
1314
"Viruses swim around hunting for cells." Outside a cell a virus is inert. It just drifts and bumps into things.
4
"Scientists have settled whether viruses are alive." Most say no by the strict definition, but it's a real, ongoing debate.
35
"All viruses make people sick." Only a tiny share of all the viruses on Earth can infect people at all; most simply bounce off our cells.
15 Many viruses infect bacteria and other microbes instead, and some phages are even used as medicine.
514
FAQ
Why are viruses not considered living organisms?
Because they fail most of the checklist biologists use for life. A virus is not made of cells, has no metabolism of its own (it can't make energy by itself), doesn't grow, and has no ribosomes to build proteins. It can only make copies of itself by getting inside a living cell and using that cell's machinery. Outside a cell, a virus is an inert particle.
Why do viruses exist if they are not living?
Something doesn't have to be alive to be copied. Any package of genes that gets itself copied more often than it's destroyed will stick around, and viruses are very good at getting cells to copy them. Scientists think viruses are extremely ancient. They may have come from genes that escaped from cells, from cells that lost parts, or they may be as old as cells themselves. Nobody knows for sure.
Where do viruses come from?
There are three main ideas. The escape idea says viruses began as bits of genetic material that gained the ability to move between cells. The reduction idea says they were once free-living cells that became parasites and lost genes. The virus-first idea says viruses came before, or alongside, the first cells. Different kinds of virus may have started in different ways.
What are the non-living characteristics of viruses?
Viruses have no cells, no cell membrane of their own, no ribosomes and no metabolism, so they can't make energy or proteins. They don't grow or develop, and they can't reproduce on their own. Outside a host cell they can't grow, make energy or make copies.
What are the living characteristics of viruses?
Viruses have genes made of DNA or RNA, they reproduce (with a host cell's help), and they evolve over time by natural selection. That's why flu vaccines are updated every year. These traits are why some scientists say viruses sit at the edge of life.
Why are viruses between living and nonliving?
Because they tick some boxes of life and not others. Outside a cell they behave like chemistry; inside a cell they take over and multiply. Giant viruses such as mimivirus, with more than a million DNA letters and some protein-making genes, blur the line even more. Whether viruses count as alive depends on exactly how you define life.
Can antibiotics kill viruses?
No. Antibiotics work on bacteria, which are living cells with their own machinery to attack. Viruses don't have that machinery, so antibiotics don't work on colds, flu or other viral infections. Most viruses never make people sick. Washing your hands with soap and water helps stop the ones that do from spreading, vaccines help prevent some viral infections, and antiviral medicines can treat some of them. This page explains how viruses work; it isn't medical advice.
Sources
- OpenStax Biology 2e, 1.2 Themes and Concepts of Biology
- OpenStax Biology 2e, 21.1 Viral Evolution, Morphology, and Classification
- Nature Education Scitable, The Origins of Viruses
- Arizona State University, Ask A Biologist: Are viruses alive?
- Microbiology Society, Are viruses alive? (Brown and Bhella, Microbiology Today)
- Scientific American, Are Viruses Alive? (Villarreal)
- Human endogenous retroviruses and cancer, Cancer Biology & Medicine (via NIH PubMed Central)
- OpenStax Biology 2e, 21.2 Virus Infections and Hosts
- OpenStax Biology 2e, 4.2 Prokaryotic Cells
- Frontiers for Young Minds, Assembly of a Microscopic Superhero: The Bacteriophage T4
- CDC, About Common Cold
- OpenStax Microbiology, 11.6 How Asexual Prokaryotes Achieve Genetic Diversity
- CDC, Antibiotic Do's and Don'ts
- OpenStax Biology 2e, 21.3 Prevention and Treatment of Viral Infections
- National Geographic, Why do only some viruses infect us? (with virologist Sara Sawyer, University of Colorado Boulder)
- CDC, About Handwashing
- WHO, Vaccines and immunization: What is vaccination?